Cedar County Sheriff's Office, Missouri
End of Watch: Thursday, October 5, 1865
Age: 41
Tour of Duty: 1 year
Badge Number: Not available
Cause of Death: Gunfire
Date of Incident: October 5, 1865
Weapon Used: Gun; Unknown type
Suspect Info: Not available
Sheriff John Payntor and Deputy Sheriff William Harville were shot and killed while trying to serve a murder warrant on two men.
Sheriff Payntor summoned six men to assist him in making the arrest and proceeded about twelve miles from Stockton, on the Oceola Road, where they arrived at the house. When Sheriff Payntor and the men entered the house they found one of the men in bed. As they approached the man he fired a weapon at Sheriff Payntor, killing him instantly. He then fired at Lieutenant Harville, killing him. A third officer in the room fired at the man but the man was able to escape with others who had been hiding outside of the house.
Sheriff Payntor had been sheriff for one year, and had previously served with the 6th Missouri Cavalry Volunteers.