Bio & Incident Details
Age: 41
Tour: Not available
Badge # Not available
Cause: Gunfire
Location: Texas
Incident Date: 8/16/1895
Weapon: Rifle
Suspect: Acquitted
· Leave a Reflection
· Add to My Heroes
· Update this memorial
Share this memorial:
During the night two masked men entered the general store in Valentine in Jeff Davis County. Asleep inside the store were U.S. Customs Inspector E.E. Townsend, a store employee and a railroad brakeman. The armed men took $325 from the safe. Unbeknownst to the robbers, a witness saw the men wearing pulled up bandanas and carrying rifles as they entered the store. The witness ran to the railroad section house and summoned J.L. Elsberry, the railroad company’s experienced night watchman and a former senior Captain of the Southern Pacific Railroad’s watchmen in El Paso. Elsberry told the witness to go to the saloon and get more help. The posse led by Deputy Sheriff Poole surrounded the store. Elsberry went to the back door and knocked. The store employee hinted that they were being robbed so Elsberry fired a one round to warn the robbers and alert the men around the store. The two robbers fled out the back door directly at Elsberry and started firing as they ran. The posse of eight citizens also opened fire. The men heard a cry of pain and Elsberry call out, “Oh my God! I’m shot!” Upon investigation Elsberry was found shot through the body by the robber’s 40-82 Winchester rifle. He died within minutes at the scene. The two robbers escaped into the night.
Two brothers, Tom and S.L. Holland, were arrested and indicted. Tom produced an alibi, but S.L. Holland was convicted of the robbery and sentenced to 15 years in prison; however, he was acquitted of the murder of Elsberry. He appealed the robbery conviction and was later acquitted. The crime remains legally unsolved.
Elsberry was survived by his wife and three children. His place of burial remains unknown.
